Palm trees along the Sunset Cliffs coastline in Point Loma at dusk.

Blog | Point Loma | Coastal San Diego

Why Do Zillow and Redfin Show Different Values for the Same Point Loma House in San Diego?

By Brandon and Lindsey Gates, The Gates Team at Compass |

Why do Zillow and Redfin show different values for the same Point Loma house in San Diego? Because each one runs its own computer model on its own set of recent sales, and neither model can see the inside of your home, its condition, its view or the block it sits on. If your house is not listed for sale, both are working with even less, and both companies report larger errors for homes that aren't listed.

The Gates Team, Brandon and Lindsey Gates with Compass in San Diego, help Point Loma homeowners price a house before they sell it and buy their next home as one plan. Here is what the two estimates are, how far off they usually run, and what to do with them.

What are a Zestimate and a Redfin Estimate?

Both are automated valuations: a computer model looks at public records and recent sales and produces a number for nearly every home, listed or not.

  • Zillow says the Zestimate draws on public records such as tax assessments and prior sales, plus listing details when a home is for sale.
  • Redfin says its estimate uses more than 500 data points about the market, the neighborhood and the home, including recent sales from the MLS and features such as a water view or a busy street.

Two different models, fed different data and weighted differently, will rarely land on the same number. That is normal, not a sign that one of them is broken.

How far off are the online estimates?

Both companies publish their own accuracy numbers. As read on November 17, 2026:

Homes listed for saleHomes not listed
Zillow, median error (nationwide)1.80%7.21%
Redfin, median error (nationwide)1.95%7.68%

A median error means half of estimates land closer than that, and half land further away.

Here is what that looks like on a typical Point Loma house. Houses in Point Loma and Ocean Beach (zips 92106 and 92107) sold for a median of $1,892,000 over the last year. On a house at that price that is not listed, a 7.21% error is about $136,000, and a 7.68% error is about $145,000. Nationwide, half of the estimates on homes that are not for sale miss by more than that.

That is why two estimates on the same Point Loma house can sit well apart from each other.

Why is the estimate closer once a house is listed?

Once a home is on the market, the models can see the list price, the photos and the listing details. Zillow says some of that information is not available when a home is off the market, so its estimate may adjust once the listing goes live.

In other words, the estimate gets more accurate once a person has already priced the home. It follows the pricing. It does not replace it.

What can't an online estimate see in a Point Loma house?

  • Condition and updates. A kitchen redone last year and one untouched since the 1960s look the same in public records. Point Loma and Ocean Beach houses that sold this year had a median build year of 1953, so how a house has been updated matters a lot.
  • The view and the lot. A bay view, a partial view, a slope, a street-facing lot or a large flat yard can move price more than the square footage does.
  • The block. Two houses a few streets apart can sell very differently.
  • What the title report shows. Easements, liens or other items on title don't show up in an estimate.

What do Point Loma houses actually sell for compared with their list price?

Across 229 Point Loma and Ocean Beach house sales with both a list price and a sold price in the MLS over the last year:

  • 64 sold above their final list price.
  • 38 sold right at list.
  • 127 sold below list.
  • The median sale came in at 99.1% of the final list price.

Pricing close to where the market is, and adjusting for what the house actually offers, is what moves a sale. The estimate is one starting point.

How should you use Zillow and Redfin before selling?

  1. Look at both, and read the range, not the single number. If they are $150,000 apart, the right price is likely somewhere in a band, not at either number.
  2. Check what the models think your house is. Bedroom count, square footage and lot size come from public records and are sometimes out of date. You can correct your home's facts on both sites.
  3. List what has changed since the last sale. Updates, additions and repairs are invisible to the models.
  4. Ask for a home value review. We compare your house with recent sales on similar streets, walk through the condition, and show you a price range with the sales behind it.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the higher estimate as the price. It is a model's guess, not an offer.
  • Treating the lower estimate as a floor. An estimate that missed your updates will undervalue the house.
  • Waiting for the estimates to agree. They may never line up, because they are built differently.

Questions Point Loma homeowners ask

Is Zillow or Redfin more accurate in San Diego? Neither company publishes a side-by-side comparison. Zillow lists a 1.74% median error for listed homes in the San Diego area. Redfin publishes nationwide figures: 1.95% for listed homes and 7.68% for homes not listed. For homes not for sale, both report nationwide median errors over 7%.

Can I fix the information Zillow and Redfin have on my house? Yes. Both sites let owners update home facts such as bedrooms, bathrooms and upgrades. That can move the estimate, but it does not replace a review of the actual house.

What is my Point Loma home worth? Houses in Point Loma and Ocean Beach (zips 92106 and 92107) sold for a median of $1,892,000 over the last year, with the middle half between $1,550,000 and $2,750,000. Where yours falls depends on the house itself. Ask us for a home value review and we will walk through it with you.

Links in this post: Point Loma home prices and sales · What's my home worth? · Seller's guide · The Move Once Method · Contact us

Sources: Zillow, "What is a Zestimate?" accuracy figures, read November 17, 2026. Redfin, Redfin Estimate accuracy, updated November 17, 2026. San Diego MLS (SDMLS), closed sales with closing dates from December 4, 2025 to November 16, 2026, zips 92106 and 92107. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Keep Reading

All Articles